Does Eric Hosmer deserve another Gold Glove?

Does Eric Hosmer deserve another Gold Glove?

The first day Eric Hosmer came to the big leagues a teammate said: “(Bleep) his bat, I want his glove.” The teammate had spent time throwing baseballs to Billy Butler and wanted someone else playing first base. That’s because first basemen make everyone else on the infield better or worse and after watching Eric Hosmer play for the past six seasons I can tell you without a doubt that Hosmer makes everyone else on the Royals infield better.

Here’s the deal :


Footwork: Good defense starts with good footwork and Hosmer excels at this. Billy Butler would get in trouble because he would often stretch for the throw too soon and then couldn’t adjust to a throw that was off-line. Hosmer wait to see the throw and then has the quick footwork required to reposition himself. He’ll go to the infield side of the first base for throws to his left and the outfield side of the first base for throws to his right. Hosmer will also go on top of the bag or into foul territory for high throws.

Hosmer’s ability to shift his position and use his 6’ 4” frame to reach for the ball gives the other infielders a much bigger target than the one presented by Billy Butler and his limited footwork.

Hands: As good as they get. Hosmer’s footwork and scooping ability give the other infielders the confidence to attempt plays they might not try with a lesser first baseman. Royals infielders know that if they keep the ball low and get it in Hosmer’s general vicinity, he’ll take care of them.

Pickoffs: Traditionally, when first basemen are holding runners they have their right foot touching the bag. They receive the pitcher’s pickoff throw and then try to tag the runner’s hand before the runner touches the bag.

Arm: We don’t think much about a first baseman’s arm, but first basemen have a whole bunch of funky throws that require different throwing techniques; underhand flips, short overhand dart throws and throws that require a full arm motion. Hitting pitchers on the run as they cover first base or throwing around a picked-off runner headed for second base requires accuracy and Hosmer have that; he’s also comfortable throwing the ball from any arm angle. Hosmer also has the arm strength necessary when required to cut a throw loose.

Pop flies: Hosmer’s range might limit what he gets to (more on that in a moment), but he’s good at catching pop-ups once he gets there. He also doesn’t mind taking charge of pop-ups in the middle of the infield, which is more important than you might think. Because the ball is spinning so fast, pop-ups curve as they come down and they’re much harder to catch than big leaguers make it look. So on a pop up in the middle of the infield, lots of guys might hang back and hope someone else takes charge. Having a tall guy willing to yell “I got it” simplifies things.

But there’s a catch:

According to advanced metrics, in 2016 Hosmer was one of the worst defensive first basemen in baseball; according to the people who play the game, Hosmer was one of the best. So what explains this wildly divergent set of opinions?

Let’s take a look at one of those advanced metrics to see if we can figure it out. I spent a decent chunk of a weekend reading about defensive metrics and one of the main ones – in one form or another—is Ultimate Zone Rating. For a basic explanation of UZR, let’s turn to the website SB Nation and the explanation I found there:

“UZR splits the field into 78 different slices called zones. Don’t worry, only 64 of those are used in the UZR formula. You figure out the average number of balls in play in each zone and then the rate at which plays made are recorded in each zone. This will give you a baseline average for the position. Now, you do this on an individual basis and graded against what the average fielder would do. If a player comes out with less plays made recorded in their zone compared to league average, they have a negative zone rating. As well, they’ll have a positive zone rating if the player records more outs in the zone than the average defender at the position.

Just to keep you up to speed: John Dewan is a former actuary – a person who compiles and analyzes statistics and uses them to calculate insurance risks and premiums – who decided baseball numbers were more fun than insurance numbers and now owns Baseball Info Solutions which provides clients with information about the National Pastime. According to, Defensive Runs Saved – another advanced metric – differs only slightly from UZR and uses BIS data in its formula.

The first time I heard about UZR I asked how the 64 zones were determined and I was told they were estimated by human scorers. I wondered whether the new tracking technology was now being utilized, so I called BIS and spoke to Jim Swavely, BIS Operations Analyst. Apparently, as of now, BIS is still using human scorers and most of the scoring is done off game video and because the scorers are at the mercy of what TV chooses to show them, some guesswork is involved. The scorers also estimate the type of ball hit and the ball’s velocity.

Here’s what FanGraphs has to say about it:

“The types of batted balls that UZR processes are ground balls, bunt groundballs, outfield line drives, and outfield fly balls (including so-called pop flies). All batted balls are put in one of those categories. The speed of the each batted ball is also considered and is indicated in the data as “slow/soft, medium, or fast/hard” (3 categories).”

So a guy watching video is estimating what kind of ball was hit and how hard that ball was hit and those estimates are combined with an estimate of where the ball was hit.

Now back to FanGraphs:

“Further adjustments are made, such as the outs and base runners, and various park adjustments, like the size and configuration of the OF, the speed of the infield, and the speed of batted balls in general, as influenced by temperature, altitude, and the ground ball percentage of the pitcher.”

That’s not all…

Let’s stop here and examine just one of the factors mentioned: speed of the infield.

Surface speed changes from park to park; if a team think its infielders have a great range they might mow the grass short to make the surface fast. If a team think it’s infielders have all the lateral movement of an Amana freezer they might leave the grass long to make the surface slow. I’ve heard of groundskeepers being asked to keep the grass in front of a first baseman short and the grass in front of a defensively challenged third baseman long. (BTW: the players think Kansas City has a fast infield.)

Ask the people in uniform about Hosmer’s range and you’ll hear his range to his glove-side is about average. His range to his arm-side is below average. So the Royals often push his positioning toward his arm-side and that can cause a problem when using UZR to compare players. Josh Stein, San Diego Padres Assistant General Manager has said UZR: “Can be skewed if the player is not starting from the exact middle of [UZR’s zone] chart.”

Learn to Jump higher

And here’s something else to think about: first basemen scoops are not included in UZR. When I asked Swavely why not, he said scoops had nothing to do with range. But as we’ve already seen, the ability to use good footwork around the bag does increase the size of the target the other infielders are throwing to.

Source: Does Eric Hosmer deserve another Gold Glove? Read and decide for yourself